This paper provides a methodology for a thorough technical comparison between traditional three-phase ac lines, on the one hand, and possible (in some cases non-conventional) alternative solutions that include HVDC lines, four-phase ac lines and combined ac-dc lines, on the other. The comparison is based on the loadability curves, which are calculated here for all the considered lines taking into account thermal limits, voltage drop, power losses and – when feasible – steady-state and transient stability. The focus is on four-phase ac and combined ac-dc lines, for which the loadability curves are derived for the first time, whereas the loadability curves of three-phase ac lines - well-known in the literature - are derived and used here just as the natural reference for the comparison. Due to the great deal of theoretical and numerical developments, the study is split in two. Part I analyzes single-circuit lines of comparable loadability at the thermal limit (three-phase, four-phase and monopolar HVDC). Part II broadens the analysis to double-circuit lines of comparable loadability at the thermal limit (three-phase, bipolar HVDC and combined ac-dc) and performs an overall comparison among the different systems in single-circuit and double-circuit configuration.
The Loadability of Overhead Transmission Lines. Part I: Analysis of Single-Circuits
QUAIA, STEFANO
2014
Abstract
This paper provides a methodology for a thorough technical comparison between traditional three-phase ac lines, on the one hand, and possible (in some cases non-conventional) alternative solutions that include HVDC lines, four-phase ac lines and combined ac-dc lines, on the other. The comparison is based on the loadability curves, which are calculated here for all the considered lines taking into account thermal limits, voltage drop, power losses and – when feasible – steady-state and transient stability. The focus is on four-phase ac and combined ac-dc lines, for which the loadability curves are derived for the first time, whereas the loadability curves of three-phase ac lines - well-known in the literature - are derived and used here just as the natural reference for the comparison. Due to the great deal of theoretical and numerical developments, the study is split in two. Part I analyzes single-circuit lines of comparable loadability at the thermal limit (three-phase, four-phase and monopolar HVDC). Part II broadens the analysis to double-circuit lines of comparable loadability at the thermal limit (three-phase, bipolar HVDC and combined ac-dc) and performs an overall comparison among the different systems in single-circuit and double-circuit configuration.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
