Is Neck Dissection Necessary After Induction Plus Concurrent Chemoradiotherapy in Complete Responder Head and Neck Cancer Patients with Pretherapy Advanced Nodal Disease?

Abstract BACKGROUND: The aim of the present study was to assess, in the setting of a single-institution prospective clinical trial, the necessity of planned neck dissection (PND) in physically and radiologically complete responders with pretherapy advanced nodal disease. METHODS: Between January 2000 and July 2007 a total of 139 patients were enrolled to receive a regimen of platinum-based multidrug induction-concurrent chemoradiotherapy (IC/CCRT). A total of 75 of the enrolled patients with advanced nodal disease were included in this retrospective study. Between 8 and 12 weeks from the end of treatment, the response to IC/CCRT was evaluated by fiber-optic endoscopy and head and neck contrast-enhanced computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging. RESULTS: The complete clinical response (cCR) rate was 68 %. Among the 51 patients who achieved locoregional cCR at the end of CCRT, 8 underwent PND according to the study recommendation. Of the 43 patients with cCR who did not undergo PND, 2 patients (4.7 %) experienced isolated regional recurrences with the 5-year regional control being 82 %. Patients with cCR did not have a significantly lower regional control compared with patients with cCR who underwent ND (P = .962). Pathological evidence of residual disease was found in 81 % of the patients with less than cCR who underwent ND. CONCLUSIONS: In physically and radiologically complete responders to IC/CCRT, a PND appears not justified. Conversely, PND should be performed in patients clinically suspected of having residual disease in the neck, as a significant proportion have viable tumor cell in post CCRT ND